​- **1984**
- James McCaffrey - Administrator
- George (Bay) Fowler - Football
- Rocky Caggiano - Administrator
- Hon. Samuel Pierce Jr. - Football
- Charles R. Scoble - Administrator
- Dr. Sid Canarick - Football
- Dominick Genova - Baseball
- Carl Karilivacz - Football
- Rocky Familetti - Baseball
- Marcus Martone - Football
- Tom Famiglietti - Baseball
- Howard Westlake - Football
- Pat Rooney Jr. - Baseball
- Tim O'Connell - Football
- Henry Boguszewski - Baseball
- Don Kunit - Football
- Angelo Paulis - Baseball
- Howard Reynolds - Football
- John (Red) Lamberson - Basketball
- Oscar Steadman - Football
- Wilhemina Young - Basketball
- Gary Wichard - Football
- Gabe Cocchiola - Basketball
- William (Boots) McCarthy - Football
- Dr. Michael Grieco - Basketball
- Amato Stanco - Football
- Bibsy Wansor - Bowling
- Joe Rizzo - Football
- John Capobianco - Boxing
- James C. Maiden - Golf
- Howard Davis Jr. - Bming
- Alex Smith - Golf
- Ziggy Nedwick - Coach
- Mal Galletta Jr. - Golf
- Charles McGurkin Sr. - Coach
- James Tingley - Golf
- Fred DiMenna - Football
- Jerry DeMeo - Lacrosse
- Gene Kunit - Football
- Marco Malusa - Soccer
- Clyde Riggins - Football
- Ed O'Rourke - Track
- Joseph (Barn) Martone - Football
- Joseph Mickens - Track
- Ed Zendle - Football
​
- **1985**
- Peter Weng - Basketball
- Edward Kasky - Football
- Charles Sumcizk - Basketball
- Morris Bessel - Football
- Frank Racanelli - Basketball
- Frank Hartmeyer - Football
- Ike Hudson - Basketball
- Donald Manfredonia - Football
- Joseph Rizzo - Baseball
- James Fantry - Football
- Eugene Gribbin - Coach
- Tiffany (Tip) Henderson - Football
- Izzy Goldstein - Football
- John Cekala - Football
- Rube Feinberg - Football
- William Nedwick - Football
- Dr. James Trousdell - Football
- Eugene Gremelsacker - Football
- Lenwood (Buddy) Spellman - Football
- Carl Lohren - Golf
- C. Edmund (Rip) Miller - Football
- Angelo Anastasio - Soccer
- George Spellman Jr. - Football
​
- **1986**
- Dr. Robert Finley - Administration
- Lou Britt - Football
- David Cohen - Administration
- William Reukauf - Football
- Anthony Zulka - Baseball
- William Boyce - Football
- Levan Smith - Coach
- Jack Matthews - Football
- George Doran - Coach
- Harry Zisk - Football
- Herbert McCue - Football
- Ben Faman - Softball
- Manuel Gonzales - Football
- Joseph Galluccio - Track-
​
**1987**
- Norm Small - Baseball
- James Malloy - Football
- Julius Famulatte - Baseball
- Leroy Cofield - Football
- Vincent Gonsowski - Baseball
- Herb Kabnick - Football
- Mike Morgal - Baseball
- Robert Gribbin - Football
- Henry Yoniak - Basketball
- Pat Rooney Sr. - Golf
- Howard Schoen - Coach
- Shirley Giambruno - Softball
- Stanley Petrowski - Football
- Joseph Stanco - Track
- Man of the Year: Father Joe, St. Hyacinth's Church
**1988**
- Joseph Reilly - Athletic Administrator
- Edward Moleski - Football
- Glenn Wagner - Auto Racing (Modified Cars)
- Theodore Clements - Football
- Carmen Santosus - Auto Racing (Stock Cars)
- James Neillands - Football
- William Pollitt - Baseball
- Charles Martone - Football
- Ben Kaplan - Boxing
- Chester Pierce - Football
- Allen Hudson Jr. - Boxing
- Vincent Wengrowski - Golf
- Joseph Phillips - Football
- Rocco Abbondandolo - Soccer
- Man of the Year: Joe Dey
-Sponsor of the Year: Abe Krasnoff, Photocircuits
​
**1989**
- Al Morra - Administration
- Joseph Bartlotti - Football
- Bobby O'Rourke - Auto Racing
- Dan Coughlin - Football
- Joseph Catanzano - Baseball
- Glenn Springman - Football
- Adrian Kenary - Baseball
- William Bennek - Football
- Philip Dileo - Baseball
- Chris Zupa - Lacrosse
- Jamie Braverman - Baseball
- Mario Morra - Soccer
- Cesar Rivera - Baseball
- Walter Widegren - Speedboat
- Edgar Applebee - Billiards
- Morris Zausmer - Sports Writer
- Anthony Sparaco - Boxing
- Ben Hendrickson - Track
- Richard Jones - Football
- James Capozzi - Umpire
- Man of the Year: Angelo Capobianco
​
**1990**
- Fred Smith - Administration
- Cornelius Wade - Football
- Joseph Schlesinger - Baseball
- Theodore Zembko - Football
- Walt Kelczewski - Baseball
- George Ostrowski - Golf
- Henry Roslund - Baseball
- Nunzio Ciampi - Golf
- Bernard (B J.) Lyttle Jr. - Football
- Lorenzo Cerasi - Soccer
- Angelo Bellissimo - Football
- Joseph Fazzari - Soccer Administration
- John Steiert - Football
- John McKim - Soccer Administration
- Alexander Bathie - Football
- Thomas Beckhard - Tennis
- Angelo Cerielli - Football
- Mark Rushmore - Track
- Man of the Year: Edwin Hoebich
​
**1991** -
- Al Martone - Administrator
- Jim Harvey - Basketball
- Nunzio Morra - Bowling
- Ralph Alois - Bowling
- John Bertone - Football
- Mike Belifore - Golf
- Al Venturino - Manager
- Herbert Beckhard - Tennis
- Walt Jankowski - Outboard Hydroplane Racer - -Ben Jankowski - Outboard Hydroplane Racer
- Karen Ann Polk - Riflery
- Mike Bednarz - Soccer
- Pasquale DeLuca - Soccer Administration
- Anthony Congero - Sports Administration
- Vinny Taranto - Sports Administration
- Man of the Year: Vinny Taranto
​
**1992**
- Desi Wilson - Baseball
- Don McDougall - Golf
- Tony DiMasso - Boxing
- Steve Muller - Soccer
- Joe Lamas - Coach
- Karen Gallego - Tennis
- Mike Ceriello - Golf
- Norman "Soupy" Barnes - Trainer
- Pat Siniscalchi - Golf
- Man of the Year: Alfred "Butch" Macedonio
- Sponsors of the Year: E. G. Hawkins & Sons, Singers Department Store
​
**1993**
- John J. Maccarone - Administration
- William Gabrus - Football
- Ken Spy - Administration
- Bill Hahn - Football
- Fred Carbuto - Basketball
- Ronald Belifore - Golf
- Teresa (Sager) Komarek - Basketball
- Tony Rosabianco - Soccer
- Allen (Donny) Seaman - Basketball
- Tony Licenziato - Soccer
- Andy Capobianco - Body Building
- Darcy Maccarone Belyea - Softball
- Man of the Year: Mike Maher
- Sponsor of the Year: Simon's Sports Shop
​
**1995**
- Frank Budzenski - Baseball
- Domenic Pedone - Soccer
- Danny Mueller - Soccer
- Person of the Year: Jean Plumb
**1997**
- Billy Blind - Baseball
- Robert Dunn - Team Handball
- Peter Zaratin - Soccer
- Man of the Year: Joe Gallo
- Sponsor of the Year: Vincent Condello (Razzano's)
​
**2000**
- Mike Anastasi - Administration
- Kristin Fullam - Basketball
- Cheryl Webb - Coach
- Edward Booth - Football
- Judith Alvarez - Golf
- James Federman - Softball
- Man of the Year: Dr. Sid Canarick
- Sponsor of the Year: Richard Belyski, Sr.
(Fairview Service Station)
​
**2003**
- Luigi Gallo - Track
- Jacquie Gow - Coach
- Marc Russo - Baseball
- Salvatore Travatello - Coach
- Man of the Year: Peter DiChiara
- Sponsors of the Year: The Nelson & Capobianco -Families (Glen Floors), The Sorenson Family (Sorenson Lumber)
​
**2005**
- Daniel Badalament - Running
- Dick Guido - Swimming
- Thomas Oriel - Lacrosse
- Diane Tull - Bowling
- Man of the Year: Honorable Richard J. McCord
- Sponsors of the Year: Joseph M. Basile Electric Service, The First National Bank of Long Island
​
**2009**
- Jon Dolecki - Coach
- Michael T. Famiglietti - Softball
- Michael Zangari - Participant & Administrator
- Man of the Year: Robin Kornoski
- Sponsor of the Year: Maccarone Plumbing
​
**2016**
- Anthony Bozzella - Coach
- John Broza - Announcer
- Susan Canarick - Tennis
- Jaime Basile Conzelman - Women's Lacrosse
- Michael Constantino III - Soccer
- Michael Grella - Soccer
- Craig Hansen - Baseball
- Sponsor of the Year: North Shore Golf Car
- Supporter of the Year: Jean Canarick
- Team of the Year: 1998 Glen Cove High School Varsity Football Team
​
**2020**
- Aja Alter - Softball
- Toni Rosabianco Cappello - Tae Kwon Do
- Frank Carrotta - Baseball
- Thomas Ecdes - Baseball
- Stefanie Graziosi - Softball
- Dustin Grasso - Football
- Delia DeRiggi-Whitton - Softball
- Sponsor of the Year: Telstar
- Supporter of the Year: Sal Travatello